This seller was recently called out on the Etsy forums:
The OP was blasted for calling out and everyone involved in the thread decided that the shop in question was probably a wholesaler who provided her products for all of the websites that they could be found on. Someone convoed the the person who was called out and she responded that her shop was a collaborative effort – she runs the shop and Amy makes all of the product.
A simple google search for “Amy’s brownie pops” brought me to this website: http://www.amysapples.com/brides/cat_12.html
and Amy is indeed the person who makes these treats. In Rhode Island. Not Salt Lake City, where The Cats Meow Favors is located. Amy is a wholesaler as well as a retailer. It would appear that the “collaboration” betweeen The Cats Meow Favors and Amy involves nothing more than placing an order.
I agree with everyone involved in the now closed thread that you can’t just go calling out a person simply because you *believe* that they are a reseller…however, the OP should have done her homework because it actually does look like The Cats Meow Favors is reselling.